Skip to main content
HelpFindGiftsSaved

Big Potato Games

Herd Mentality

Works for mixed-age family gatherings at Christmas.

British brand

Where to buy

We do not sell this. These are the shops where we checked it, by country. Prices change; the shop's page is always the final word.

Sold to: United Kingdom. We may earn a commission if you buy through these links. How we make money

Why it made our lists

  • Gifts for board game and puzzle fans

    Everyone tries to give the same answer as the majority, and the odd one out gets the cow. For a big mixed-age family gathering at Christmas. Flat with only three or four.

  • Christmas gift ideas

    A party game where everyone tries to give the majority answer, with a cow token for the odd one out. Built for a big mixed-age family Christmas. It falls flat with only three or four players.

  • Gifts for a friendBest on a budget

    A party game where everyone tries to give the same answer as the group, with a cow token for the odd one out. Cheap and good for a friend who hosts big gatherings. It falls flat with only three or four players.

  • Gifts for your brother or sister

    A party game where everyone tries to give the majority answer, for a sibling who hosts big family gatherings at Christmas. Best with a big group; flat with three or four.

  • Gifts for teens

    A party game where everyone tries to match the majority answer. Works for a teen who hosts friends or for mixed-age family gatherings. It is flat with three or four players, so buy it for groups.

  • Secret Santa gift ideas

    A party game where you try to give the same answer as everyone else, with a cow token for the odd one out. A good pick if the Secret Santa ends with a party. It is flat with only three or four players.

What it is

A party game where everyone tries to give the same answer as the majority, with a cow token for the odd one out. It plays with large groups.

A party game where each player writes an answer to a question and scores a cow token only by matching what most of the group wrote. Anyone who gives the lone odd answer gets stuck with the pink cow, which stops them winning until someone else takes it. There is no right or wrong answer, so it works across ages. Rounds are quick and it handles large groups.

The details

Players
4 to 20
Age
10 and up
Play time
20 minutes
Question cards
200

In the box

  • 200 question cards
  • 62 cow tokens
  • 2 answer pads
  • 1 squishy cow
  • 1 cow paddock
  • Rules sheet

From the shop's product page, read October 3, 2026.

Worth knowing

Best with a big group; flat with three or four.

Skip it for a household of two or three, since it needs at least four players.

Good for
Brother or sister, Friend, Teen (13–17)
Interests
Board games & puzzles
Occasions
Christmas, Secret Santa
Age
10+

Something wrong with this listing? Tell us and we will check it.

Similar gifts